Year A
Twenty-third Ordinary Sunday
Images
I am my brother’s keeper
Points to note
Last week, we dealt with
how Jesus reacted to Peter who made a mistake.
This Sunday, we deal with a central theme in our everyday life: What do we do when someone else makes a
mistake?
Care must be taken to
ensure that the discussion does not centre on the mistake that the someone else
did, but rather on our reaction to that mistake. Some children are notorious as ‘tell-tales’
and intervention is often required to keep the discussion on track.
Liturgy
Acclamation before the Gospel
Alleluia! Alleluia!
Your word is truth, O Lord,
consecrate us in the truth.
Alleluia!
Gospel
This
passage takes place after the Transfiguration, and Jesus was discussing with
his disciples about the Church.
The Lord be with you.
All: And also with your spirit.
A Reading from the Holy Gospel according to St
Matthew
All: Glory to you O Lord
(Mt 18: 15-20)
Jesus said to his
disciples: “If your brother does something wrong, go and have it out with him
alone, between your two selves. If he
listens to you, he has won back your brother.
If he does not listen, take one or two others with you: the evidence of two or three witnesses is
required to sustain any charge. But if
he refuses to listen to these, report it to the community; or if he refuses to
listen to the community, treat him like a leper or a tax collector.
“I tell you solemnly,
whatever you bind on earth shall be considered bound in heaven; whatever you
considered loose on earth shall be considered loosed in heaven.
“I tell you solemnly once
again, if two of you on earth agree to ask anything at all, it will be granted
to you by my Father in heaven. For where
two or three meet in my name, I shall be there with them.”
This is the Gospel of the
Lord
Discussion
Have you heard of the
saying ‘I am not my brother’s keeper’?
It was Cain’s response when God asked him where Abel was (Gn 4:9). What kind of person was Cain? He
murdered his brother, Abel. You may wish
to go through the story of why Cain killed Abel - because Cain got jealous when
God liked Abel’s sacrifice more than Cain’s.
Discuss the type of person who would use the saying - someone who is
afraid or not bothered about his brother.
Explain that ‘brother’ in this context, does not just refer to a member
of the family, but to any member of the community.
Have you ever seen your
brother or sister in the family done something wrong? Careful
here, we do not want a long diatribe of dirty linen being washed in
public!! Damper it down if necessary and
move on. Note that this does not refer
to wrongdoing done by the child, but by others
Point
out that even if it were a wrongdoing where no one gets hurt, Mom and Dad would
still be angry. Discuss what the child
would do if Mom and Dad still haven't found out. Would they tell at the first instance, or
would they remonstrate with the wrongful sibling? If the sibling were still unrepentant, would
the child then inform the parents? I
find that in many circumstances, there is no right and wrong answer to this
question. Even for us as adults, or
maybe, especially for us as adults (would you turn in your own child if he/she
commits a crime? A small crime? A big crime?). So, don’t be dogmatic with the answer.
If
there is time, expand the discussion to brothers and sisters in the community.
Explain to the children that as the
Church is one family, it also has a head like our parents at home. As head of the Church, God would not like it
if somebody in the family sins. As a
member of the family, we have a responsibility to do for a fellow member of our
community what we should do for our sibling at home who has done any
wrongdoing.